Why Matlock Deserves an Emmy Nod in 2025: A Case for Underdog Recognition
As the 2025 Emmy nomination voting closed on June 23, industry insiders and fans alike are bracing for the usual mix of expected nominees and potential shockers. While buzzy streaming hits often dominate the headlines, it’s the underdog contenders that spark the most excitement — the unexpected gems that sneak into the conversation and remind us why we love awards season in the first place.
One such underdog? CBS’s Matlock reboot — and it’s time the Television Academy paid attention.
A Modern Reboot of a Beloved Classic
Yes, Matlock — the iconic courtroom drama — is back, and it’s better than ever. Reimagined for 2024, the reboot stars the legendary Kathy Bates as Madeline Matlock, a sharp, seasoned attorney inspired by the original character played by Andy Griffith. The new series brings fresh energy and relevance while preserving the classic charm that made the original a hit.
Joining Bates is an impressive ensemble cast including Jason Ritter, Leah Lewis, David Del Rio, and Skye P. Marshall, each adding layers to the show’s dynamic storytelling. The updated Matlock doesn’t rely on nostalgia alone — it dives into modern legal issues with intelligence, empathy, and gravitas.
Why Emmy Voters Should Take Notice
Despite critical praise and a dedicated fanbase, procedural dramas like Matlock often face an uphill climb at the Emmys — especially when airing on traditional broadcast networks like CBS. Streaming giants continue to dominate the awards race, often overshadowing network programming that delivers equally strong, if not stronger, storytelling.
But Matlock deserves to break that trend. It’s a smart, character-driven legal drama that tackles weighty themes like justice, ageism, and institutional bias — all while delivering courtroom intrigue in a refined, tightly-written format. It’s time for Emmy voters to acknowledge that network procedurals can be just as compelling and layered as their streaming counterparts.
Kathy Bates: A Powerhouse Performance
Kathy Bates has long been recognized as one of the most formidable actresses of her generation, and her role as Madeline Matlock only cements that reputation. In this role, Bates masterfully combines warmth with toughness, intellect with emotion, and legacy with reinvention. Her portrayal is commanding without being overwhelming, subtle yet incredibly impactful.
This performance is more than a reboot — it’s a bold reinterpretation of a beloved character, told through the lens of experience, age, and evolving American values. Bates brings both humor and heart, delivering Emmy-worthy moments in every episode.
Tackling Real-World Themes with Intelligence
Far from being formulaic, the new Matlock excels at balancing episodic structure with deeper thematic storytelling. Each case explores timely issues such as corporate corruption, wrongful convictions, and social justice — topics that feel ripped from today’s headlines. The writers manage to engage viewers with legal drama while also inviting reflection on the systems that shape our society.
The reboot proves that traditional courtroom dramas can evolve with the times — and even lead the conversation.
A Stellar Supporting Cast and Episodic Depth
Much like CBS’s other Emmy hopeful Elsbeth, Matlock benefits from a strong supporting cast and guest appearances that elevate each episode. The chemistry between characters, the sharp dialogue, and the layered performances all contribute to the show’s richness.
There’s a case to be made that shows like Matlock are quietly redefining “prestige television” — not by flashy gimmicks, but through solid storytelling, powerful performances, and thoughtful social critique.
The Emmy Bias Against Network Dramas Must End
Historically, the Emmys have overlooked network procedural dramas in favor of streaming sensations. But as recent hits like Poker Face and The Residence have proven, that bias is increasingly out of step with the current TV landscape. Shows like Matlock offer the same — if not greater — levels of emotional complexity, narrative ambition, and cultural relevance.
The Verdict: It’s Time for Recognition
With the official Emmy nominations set to be announced on July 15, now is the moment to rally behind shows that truly deserve recognition. Matlock isn’t just a reboot — it’s a reawakening of the courtroom genre, led by one of television’s finest talents in Kathy Bates.
If Emmy voters are serious about honoring excellence in storytelling, they must look beyond the streaming hype and reward shows that deliver substance and soul. Let Matlock be the surprise nomination that restores balance to the Emmy race — and proves that great television isn’t defined by platform, but by power.
